≡ Menu

Weekend reading: Will the stock market go up in 2022?

Weekend reading logo

What caught my eye this week.

All of us know that a calendar year is an arbitrary period over which to measure non-astronomical progress. That’s true whether you’re looking at an expanding portfolio or a shrinking waistline. Or, worse, the opposite!

Yet 90% of us do it anyway.

Far be it from me to take the high ground here. Not when one of my favourite rituals of the quiet New Year is resetting my return tracking spreadsheet.

I love pressure washing the slate clean. Percentages gained and lost and my benchmarks are zeroed. So too is the chunky annual expense tally that’s racked up by my naughty active style.

I try to be happy that my transaction taxes pay for a new nurse somewhere, and resolve to do better.

I also resolve to eat less fried food, and to read more books and fewer Tweets.

We’ll see.

Money for nothing

If tracking annual returns is illogical, forecasting them is insanity.

Yet plenty of well-paid professionals do that, too.

As a financial media junkie, this time of the year sees me digest a hotpot of forecasts from everyone from hedge fund managers and market strategists to bank interns.

They aim to pin the tail on a donkey, by predicting where the world’s biggest stock market indices will sit in exactly 12 months.

Such precision is, of course, errant nonsense.

Nobody knows where the market will be tomorrow, next month, or in a year. Most market prediction methods don’t predict much of anything. Animal spirits loom large – not to mention pandemics caught from animals.

True, over the very long-term GDP growth and stock markets are related in healthy economies. Prices of assets ultimately follow earnings. The price you pay affects the returns you get, so valuation does matter.

But ‘ultimately’ is doing a lot of heavy lifting there. Think decades.

Short-term, anything can happen. For example, consider how the immense contraction in GDP in early 2020 foreshadowed a boom in shares. Nobody saw that coming. Just saying the world wasn’t ending felt contrarian enough.

Still, I’ve also mellowed about these market forecasts. It helps that wider scrutiny via the Internet means fewer people take these horoscopes as gospel nowadays.

Most market mystics just slap roughly 10% on to wherever the stock market sat at the end of the year just passed and call it job done. And in truth that’s about as good a guess as any.

There are more important things to be cross about than pragmatism.

Sultans of swing

Where the pundits do spin stories to justify their +10% forecast – beyond it being an (optimistic) historical near-norm, twiddled for inflation – you can also get an insight into what’s driving the big money.

It’s similar to how some stock pickers start with a company’s market cap, then work back to see what assumptions are being made about its earnings and growth. You can do the same with these wider prognostications.

In an era where people are flipping blockchain-ed JPGs of cartoon monkeys for millions of dollars on a daily basis, thinking about how the stock market might move over a long 12-month period – and why – seems almost sagely.

Right now investors seem to foresee rates rising, but at a moderate pace. Real yields are expected to remain low, historically-speaking. Quantitative tightening (yep, it’s a thing) should eventually drain some liquidity from the system, but it’s thought more normal economic conditions will pick up the slack. Crucially, inflation isn’t expected to run hot indefinitely.

That summary might not sound like anything to scare the horses. But it’s already been enough to crash the highly-rated ‘disruptive’ growth stocks that boomed during the pandemic.

As Michael Batnick points out:

The story that best encapsulates investor enthusiasm for growth stocks was when Zoom’s market cap crossed ExxonMobil [XOM], which traces its roots back to 1870.

When Zoom went public in 2019, XOM was 21x the size. And then, for one brief moment during the pandemic, Zoom took the lead. After the recent growth crash, Exxon is now 5.5x larger. Order has been restored to the galaxy.

Multiple compression has done a number on these stocks. The median price to sales ratio for ARKK names peaked in February at 33 (Zoom got up to 120) and is now down to 10.5.

So much for the highest-fliers. If anything they’re starting to look more like buys than sells to my spidey senses, if you’ve a long enough time horizon.

Your latest trick

A question mark also hangs over what we used to call ‘bond proxies’ in the old days. (You know, those ancient times before March 2020).

These are the high-quality, slower growers like Nestle and Diageo. The sort of companies beloved of star fund managers Nick Train and Terry Smith.

Shares in many such firms have been stagnant for a while but – especially outside of the UK – their valuations remain largely unattractive on a historical basis. Yet the same financial modeling that sees higher yields compressing racy tech stocks should also imply lower multiples for these chocolate makers and whiskey merchants, albeit not to the same degree. I’m watching these companies very closely for clues.

Then finally we have the value stocks – banks, miners, energy firms and the like.

The presumption is rising rates, inflation, and economic growth are good for these because future higher earnings aren’t so valuable as they are in a low-growth, low-yield world. Hence the market sees more rotation into such companies.

For what it’s worth (nothing) I’m not so sure. A lot of assumptions underpin that trade. I find it hard to be confident of an economic boom, with Covid still raging a year on from vaccine euphoria. I believe too that supply chains and consumers alike are getting better at dealing with the pandemic’s impacts. That’s one reason I don’t see high inflation persisting.

Brothers in arms

It’s possible – especially in European markets, which has less of a growth and tech focus – that money could continue to rotate from one kind of company and into another, and the market still head higher.

Individual fund manager or factor returns could crater, depending on style. But index investors might barely feel a flesh wound.

So will the market go up in 2022? Your guess is as good as mine.

Instead of an unsatisfactory answer, a better question: which market?

This graph from Visual Capitalist illustrates a wide variety of moves across asset classes in 2021:

That’s from the perspective of a US investor, but the message is universal.

Diversification potentially gives you more leg-ups and safety ropes in an uncertain future. Whereas betting on just UK value shares or US software-as-a-service or whatnot – or even only shares or cash – is exactly that. A gamble.

If you want more soothsaying for the year ahead, try Saxo Bank’s annual outrageous predictions. They’re tongue-in-cheek, and interesting.

Happy 2022!

From Monevator

The Slow & Steady Passive Portfolio update: Q4 2021 – Monevator

From the archive-ator: We’ve just lived through a ten-year bear market – Monevator


Note: Some links are Google search results – in PC/desktop view you can click to read the piece without being a paid subscriber. Try privacy/incognito mode to avoid cookies. Consider subscribing if you read them a lot!1

UK house prices rise at fastest pace since 2007, but end to the boom in sight – Guardian

Millions more face fuel poverty, with average bill forecast to hit £2,240 by April – ThisIsMoney

HMRC temporarily waives late filing and payment charges on tax returns – Which

UK children to get inflation-busting pocket money boost – Guardian

How to get 62 days off work in 2022 by using only 26 days of annual leave – Mirror

London’s Crossrail is still uncertain on opening dates – New Civil Engineer

David Bowie’s estate has sold his back catalogue for at least $250m – Variety

Influencer who made £38,000 a week selling her farts in a jar is hospitalized; blames unsustainable withdrawal rate – Metro

Visualizing the $94 trillion global economy – Visual Capitalist

Products and services

Savings rates stuck at rock bottom despite BOE rate rise  – ThisIsMoney

Open a SIPP with Interactive Investor and pay no SIPP fee for six months. Terms apply – Interactive Investor

Vanguard suffers a rare major website SNAFU – RIA Biz

Amazon Prime members can get free Deliveroo delivery – ThisIsMoney

Promo / free money Join the 400,000 people saving with a FSCS-protected Chip account, and we’ll both get a free £10. Download the Chip app here then head to the ‘Promos & Referrals’ section on your profile and enter the code CHIP-EBZ267

Converted homes for sale, in pictures – Guardian

Comment and opinion

10 things the FIRE gurus don’t want you to know – Early Retirement Now

For retirees, when inflation arrives is important – Morningstar

Who you should know – Humble Dollar

Feeling rich – Fire V London

The rise of the meme stock financiers – Wired

21 personal finance rules from a Harvard economist – CNBC

Reflections on three years of early retirement – Minafi

What if the bull market keeps going? – The Irrelevant Investor

Crypt o’ crypto

Unrest in Kazakhstan deals a blow to global Bitcoin mining – Guardian

GameStop shares surge on plans for an NFT marketplace – Ars Technica

Bitcoin could hit $100,000 in five years, says Goldman Sachs – ThisIsMoney

Naughty corner: Active antics

Rising energy prices could upset the stock market, so hedge by owning energy firms [Search result]FT

Cathie Wood makes the case again for disruptive growth [Video] – via YouTube

How institutions like pensions might better pick fund managers – Verdad

Why it could be a better time to bet against Buffett… – Compound Advisors

… but maybe not Berkshire Hathaway – The Belle Curve

Stock market history, illuminated – Albert Bridge Capital

New year, old case for value vs growth divergence closing – bps and pieces

So there’s a Groundhog Day anomaly [Research]Science Direct

Upgrade your life in 2022 mini-special

Sleep more – Humble Dollar

100 ways to slightly improve your life without really trying – The Guardian

Lessons from an 85-year old aunt – Flow

Dare to dream – Banker on FIRE

How to live a rich life – I Will Teach You To Be Rich

Give your money. Give your time. Don’t tell anyone – The Atlantic

Covid corner

Latest data from London offers glimmer of hope in Omicron wave… – Sky

…though this scary thread collates research about long Covid… – via Twitter

…and more on the downside of Omicron as a ‘pandemic killer’ – Infection Control Today

Moderna CEO says fourth Covid shot may be needed later this year – CNBC

Dear Djokovic: patience with vaccine sceptics is wearing thin – Guardian

Upgrade your mask – N.Y. Mag

Omicron may not be the final variant, but it may be the final variant of concern – The Conversation

Kindle book bargains

Mastering the Market Cycle by Howard Marks – £0.99 on Kindle

The 5AM Club: Own Your Morning by Robin Sharma – £0.99 on Kindle

Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance by Angela Duckworth – £0.99 on Kindle

Environmental factors

A history of plastic, and its polluting future – The Atlantic

The return of the urban firestorm – N.Y. Mag

Australian frogs hurt by disease and climate change – Gloucester Advocate

Human brain drains mini-special

Do Your Own Research? – New York Times

Does not compute – Morgan Housel

Off our beat

Five lessons humans can learn from dogs – Undercover Fund Manager

Skateboarding in middle-age – Guardian

This 30-year old’s company makes millions flipping Walmart clearance aisle products on Amazon – CNBC

Five ways the Internet era has changed British English – The Conversation

And finally…

“Remember that the only purpose of money is to get you what you want, so think hard about what you value and put it above money. How much would you sell a good relationship for? There’s not enough money in the world to get you to part with a valued relationship.”
– Ray Dalio, Principles

Like these links? Subscribe to get them every Friday! Note this article includes affiliate links, such as from Amazon. We may be compensated if you pursue these offers, but that will not affect the price you pay.

  1. Note some articles can only be accessed through the search results if you’re using PC/desktop view (from mobile/tablet view they bring up the firewall/subscription page). To circumvent, switch your mobile browser to use the desktop view. On Chrome for Android: press the menu button followed by “Request Desktop Site”. []
{ 16 comments… add one }
  • 1 Tom-Baker Dr Who January 7, 2022, 8:16 pm

    Reading the section heads in this post I can’t help thinking that we’ll be in Dire Straits in 2022 😉

  • 2 Tyro January 7, 2022, 9:52 pm

    Yup, section heads and the Dalio finisher …. Love over Gold

  • 3 JimJim January 8, 2022, 8:32 am
  • 4 Gentleman's Family Finances January 8, 2022, 10:37 am

    Prediction is a fools game – they are all either “steady as she goes” / “cautiously optimistic” or bat shit Nostradamus stuff.
    Luckily, we don’t have to really care too much about the future because the present is bamboozling enough!

  • 5 Old_eyes January 8, 2022, 12:51 pm

    “ 1Tom-Baker Dr Who
    January 7, 2022, 8:16 pm
    Reading the section heads in this post I can’t help thinking that we’ll be in Dire Straits in 2022 ”

    Hah! Beat me too it, I was going to post exactly the same!

  • 6 SemiPassive January 8, 2022, 1:11 pm

    It has been a good start to the year as I was already skewed heavily to income/dividends/value and hardly exposed to tech, so long may the rotation continue. Of course I lost out compared to the S&P500 last year, but an overall 15% return wasn’t too bad.

    Energy is a big part of the mix, BlackRock Energy and Resources Income Trust is up about 68% in value from my average buy price over the last 2 years yet still cranking out nearly 4% in dividend yield.
    I have a couple of green energy infrastructure trusts and looking to add a couple more over the next year or two in both wind and solar.
    So renewables will eventually make up quite a chunky allocation due to their fairly resilient income streams. And owning National Grid also takes away some of the bitterness of electricity bill hikes.

    As for predictions, I will be happy if we end the year more or less flat on the main indices but with a nice slug of dividend cash to reinvest. It is great seeing compounding in action.
    Other than that, NASDAQ to end the year lower, US T 10 Year to hit 2%, UK 10 year gilts 1.5%.
    Old fashioned equity income investment trusts to outperform S&P500 – which will end the year +/- 5% where it is now.
    And probably VWRL to beat all of the above.

    Or maybe Harry Dent will be right this year and there will be an 80% crash.

  • 7 BillD January 8, 2022, 3:50 pm

    Thanks for the links. If we made it through 2020 and 2021, as for 2022 – Why Worry? Happy New Year and good luck to all. No idea what’s coming but I’m hoping for some sunshine after the rain

  • 8 far_wide January 8, 2022, 5:33 pm

    It seems strange to see Bitcoin sitting at the top of that table, for a few reasons:

    1) Is BTC an asset class? surely that would be Crypto at large. If it counts, can we also put GME on there as representing the meme stock asset class? +687% on the year if you were wondering. Dive in, lads.

    2) It also seems strange as anyone who follows it will know that it’s currently in it’s own little bear market, down 38%+ from its highs.

    3) Finally, just for fun, if we measure the year from today (January 8th), then the return is just 2.3%. To be fair, if we go back a week instead of forward and do Dec 25th 2020 – Dec 25th 2021, it’s 97%!

    In short, the placement of Bitcoin there as a leading asset class of 2021 is the embodiment of TI’s point about the arbitrary nature of the calendar year.

  • 9 far_wide January 8, 2022, 5:40 pm

    Predictions? Well, actions speak louder than words. I’ve, with not a little mental anguish, sold down 5% of my equity holdings on Jan 4th to re=balance towards defensive assets. I’ve plucked mostly VWRL and left the pure Value/UK/ holdings untouched.
    It’s not really a prediction of course, but it feels high time to rebalance a little away from equities. The US stock market seeing a CAPE of 40. Analysts desperately creating new measure of how to value the stock market because the old tools come up with such preposterous results.
    It all just feels to me like it’s time to step back a little. The regret I’ll feel if equities continue to soar and I benefit a little less from that is less than the regret I’ll feel if the markets plunge 50% and I’m left with less in defence than I otherwise would have.

  • 10 EarlyRetirementNow January 8, 2022, 6:24 pm

    Thanks! It’s a great honor to be included in your always excellent weekend reading list! You’re the best!

  • 11 The Investor January 9, 2022, 12:30 pm

    @JimJim — Yes I’m seeing quite a few signs that the supply chain snaggles are peaking. Inventories in some sectors are also building, which may suggest the supply chain congestion was exacerbated by companies over-ordering in *fear* of going short. Thus we could see a roll-over on a few metrics soon, and then perhaps a smaller re-reversal. As I said at the start of the lockdowns, I picture the economy re-starting like a machine juddering and shaking gas out of the pipes etc. It’s bumpy. 🙂

    @GFF @BillD — Quite. We’re in one of those periods where people can’t even agree on what recently happened (White House invasion, motivation for Brexit) so let’s leave getting truly to grips with the next 12 months to our future selves 😉

    @Far_Wide — Agreed, Bitcoin is increasingly (or decreasingly, recently 😉 ) just one instance of the crypto asset class. I hadn’t quite realized how much better Ethereum (which I own a tiny bit of, much less than my infamous Bitcoin) had done over the past 12 months. Perhaps I’ll chuck another few hundred quid on that bonfire this week.

    @ERN — Very kind and you’re very welcome, thanks for stopping by and commenting. You’ve got some big fans around here!

    @Semi-Passive — Similar to my take (albeit as I said above I’m already re-upping some disruptive growth). I’ve been trying to rotate into UK equity income then getting mostly spooked back out for the past 15 months or so. I’ve made a few pennies but largely missed the pounds! My mother’s investment trust portfolio (which I manage for her in an infinitely more lazy fashion than my own) is mostly in UK equity income and was smashed in March 2020 but is already above its all-time highs. I wouldn’t be surprised if she beats me in 2022. I’d be very surprised if she does over the next five years though.

    @TBDW @Tyro @old_eyes — Pleased to meet you on the Telegraph Road. 😉

  • 12 Jim January 9, 2022, 6:52 pm

    Following the Djokovic story with interest. Pity it’s a leftie guardian link. Can’t wait to see the result in the morning. 1 rule for all, except 3 lesser profile players have already been let in with same exemption. 1 now having been voluntarily deported. Seems to me Australia won’t come out of it looking good whatever the result. From a financial perspective he’s still favourite on Betfair exchange I thought I might get some long odds!

  • 13 JimJim January 10, 2022, 7:48 am

    I’m more interested in the odds of Trump staying out of jail this year. Having followed Aussie politics for a while now, I don’t think this will be anything other than a side show in a s**t show. Perhaps even a chance to bury bad news or another sneaky handout to a friend of Scotty from marketing or the coal industry. All good entertainment.
    An article that might signal the fall of Mr MAGA??? https://www.salon.com/2022/01/08/donald-should-be-very-afraid-this-anniversary-was-not-good-news-for-him/

  • 14 The Investor January 10, 2022, 11:05 am

    @JimJim — Given that as many as two-thirds of US Republican voters witlessly believe the US election was stolen, I’m not sure whether Trump being jailed would be better or worse for US democracy in pragmatic terms. (The country must follow the rule of law, regardless, and due process.)


    Watching Brexit supporters shapeshift to claim that Brexit still has the potential to be a boon for the UK (an intellectually credible position would be closer to ‘might not yet do more damage’, which would also be wide of the mark) or the wilder fringes of the ongoing anti-vax pandemic, I see 2022 as potentially yet another dangerous lurch towards some horrible conclusion years from now. 😐

    Still, disruptive tech might be due a bounce! 😉

  • 15 jim January 11, 2022, 4:16 pm

    @jimjim Whoever advises Scotty would be getting the sack soon i’d imagine. A complete own goal by those fools. Now left in the no win position of letting the judgement stand and appearing weak or cancelling the visa anyway under special powers.

  • 16 Calculus January 12, 2022, 4:29 pm

    @TI Id agree it looks like not the worst time to add some Ethereum and today may be some sort of recovery from the most recent ‘crash’. I added back middle of last year and have enough to be going on with. I’ve also added some smaller alt chain coins since but these may not be for the long term especially with an eye to Eth v2. I’m putting the Eth to work in Liquidity Pooling (via Uniswap v3 smart contracts) wherein a fixed % trade fee is returned to the pool. Its a little complicated to set up, needs paired with another eg stable coin and the gas fees are horrendous, but to my mind there’s more transparency and less platform risk in this as an earn option than some. There are other risks such as contract bugs/failure. So far so good, the beauty is that the fees earn in proportional to volume/volatility up and down, and if there’s one thing about crypto its that!

Leave a Comment