≡ Menu

Can you commit to your investing strategy for the long-term?

Investing should be all about the long-term. Yet almost everyone who grabs our attention when it comes to investing – media pundits, asset managers, brokers – have an incentive to keep us guessing about the state of the market, and the performance of individual shares and funds.

  • Magazines and websites want us to tune in and ideally pay up to hear the latest news and views.
  • Fund managers want us to recognise their apparent skill and then switch to their funds.
  • Brokers want us to trade our holdings. And then to trade them again.
  • Even non-financial companies may benefit from a febrile atmosphere if they need to tap the markets through rights issues, IPOs, or spin-offs.

Heck, even the tax man would probably prefer we churn our portfolios. In the UK most share purchases are liable for stamp duty tax, and most investments sold for a gain outside of ISA or pension face capital gains tax, too.

Whatever you do, don’t do it

There are big problems with being too concerned about the meanderings of the stock market when you’re a private investor.

Active investors who are overly obsessed with day-to-day market noise and commentary are more likely to feel the need to do something – which usually means trading shares or swapping funds their around.

Too much of trading increases expenses and will likely reduce your returns. And most of the time, when people swap funds they are chasing performance, which can have a damaging impact over the long-term, as they repeatedly sell low and buy high.

Yet even passive investors can suffer if they’re partial to weather reports and horoscopes stock market updates and analysts’ commentary.

A well-balanced asset allocation can be derailed if you react to some super-smooth pundit opining about asset classes, touting that “only a fool would own government bonds right now” or claiming that “This is surely a once in a lifetime chance to invest in the Democratic Republic of Congo!”

Then there’s the worst fate of all – being scared out of your positions at the bottom of a bear market, and missing out on the rebound.

Stick to the plan, Stan

Sticking to your long-term plan is vital for success, as this video from Sensible Investing TV explains:

As Vanguard founder Jack Bogle says:

“Why in the name of peace do we pay any attention to the stock market? The stock market is a derivative.

The stock market is a derivative of what? It’s a derivative of the earning power and dividend yields on, in the case of this nation, US corporations.

The dividend yield, plus the earnings growth that follows, is what creates the fundamental return on stocks.

The speculative return on stocks, compared to that investment return, is how much people are willing to pay for a dollar of earnings.

That carries the market up and down, and in the long run, in the last 100 years, the contribution of speculative return to total market return is zero.

The contribution of investment return, if you happen to have 4.5% dividend yield and 4.5% earnings growth, that’s the 9% you read about in the past for the US market.

Bogle’s conclusion? The stock market is a giant distraction to the business of investing.

Most people are best off ignoring it like you’d ignore the tantrums of a greedy and tired child, and letting long-term compound interest work its magic.

Check out the rest of the videos in this series.

Receive my articles for free in your inbox. Type your email and press submit:

{ 6 comments… add one }
  • 1 Sean October 24, 2014, 12:11 pm

    Love these tips to help us manage our emotional weaknesses. Another variant of this theme is to consider yourself a buyer of units not a buyer of stock price. If you focus on accumulating units, it helps to mitigate against worrying about (short term) price swings.

  • 2 RetirementInvestingToday October 24, 2014, 12:36 pm

    Commiting long term. It’s an essential part of my strategy and I’ve now ‘stayed the course’ since 2007. I must say having a clearly written strategy that is mechanical in nature plus copes with behaviour over time really does take the emotion out of it and really helps you ignore the noise. Personally, I’m finding it very effective but it’s now pretty boring. I guess I just have to tolerate the boredom to get the performance.

  • 3 magneto October 24, 2014, 4:17 pm

    ” I must say having a clearly written strategy that is mechanical in nature plus copes with behaviour over time really does take the emotion out of it and really helps you ignore the noise”


  • 4 The Rhino October 24, 2014, 4:48 pm

    @RIT have you read this: http://theescapeartist.me/2014/10/22/how-much-is-enough/
    i’m trying to save you a few years 😉 you definitely fulfill the EA criteria – it makes me sad when I read about you dialling back your SWR

    PS where do you get your CAPE data from – i’ve been trying to find some worldwide stuff, e.g. CAPE by country but had no luck, only the odd journalist article on the subject..

  • 5 elmar October 24, 2014, 6:16 pm

    I have a written investment strategy. It’s just paper. Emotions do get in the way from time to time. Still learning.

    I have come to the conclusion that I need to completely ignore the financial media and stick to my AA plus rebalancing schedule.

    Everything else sucks. Sorry.

  • 6 Tyro October 24, 2014, 6:24 pm

    @The Rhino

    Try http://www.researchaffiliates.com – new asset allocation website with CAPE info.


Leave a Comment