≡ Menu

Push me pull you with the 2022 Mini Budget

A push me pull you costume

A barely-known Prime Minister, a mysterious chancellor – and a plan with the feel of a 1980s fancy dress party.

It’s back to the future in Downing Street for the UK’s third policy reset in a decade.

The UK government’s 2022 Mini Budget cuts taxes and aims to boost growth even as the Bank of England is elsewhere applying the brakes.

Which is not to say that PM (and sometime royal stand-in) Liz Truss and chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng aren’t doing the right thing in cutting taxes now and putting off the bill for later.

Time will tell. But the UK economy was hardly humming under the prior plans, and there’s case for trying something different.

In particular productivity has been in a rut for a decade:

Source: LSE/ONS

Truly woeful, and there’s something for everyone when it comes to allocating the blame.

That LSE paper points to Britain’s exposure to financial services during the 2008-2009 crisis, the follow-up austerity drive, too little investment in infrastructure, and the ongoing drag from Brexit.

A right-wing perspective would foreground the relentless expansion of the State.

Others might blame UK PLC’s reliance on cheap labour rather than investing in technology.

More recently, the pandemic won’t have helped.

Pick your poison. There’s clearly a sickness here.

As for the cure, I’m sure there’s a political dimension to the bottle that PM Truss has reached for. But at least I’m heartened by her claim she’s willing to be unpopular. Her admission – six years after Brexiteers blathered that it would be an easy prize – that no US/UK trade deal is coming anytime soon is a start.

Populism has done great harm in recent years. The spell can’t be broken soon enough if we’re to make the best of where it’s left us.

The 2022 Mini Budget highlights

Which brings us to those tax cuts and reversals and the other just-announced measures.

Here’s a summary of Friday’s Mini Budget from the BBC:

– The basic rate of income tax will be cut by 1p to 19p from April 2023

– The 45p tax rate for top earners over £150,000 will be abolished, also from April next year

– The level at which house-buyers begin to pay stamp duty is doubled from £125,000 to £250,000

– First-time buyers will pay no stamp duty on homes worth £450,000, up from £300,000

– Planned rise on corporation tax from 19% to 25% is scrapped

– A 1.25% rise in National Insurance to be reversed from 6 Novemnber

– Cap on bankers’ bonuses, which limited rewards to twice the salary level, is axed

– Cost of subsidising both domestic and business energy bills will cost £60bn for the next six months

-Strike action: unions will be required to put offers to members during pay talks

– UK to introduce sales tax-free shopping for overseas visitors

Expect more to emerge as journalists and wonks dig into the detail.

Just one example – the controversial IR35 legislation is to be repealed.

The big picture take is the UK government is cutting its income even as its outgoings rise with inflation and the higher cost of servicing debt.

Oh, and the rich have just gotten richer.

Short-term this looks optically bad, but it isn’t entirely mad. You could even argue its conventional counter-cyclical Keynesian economics.

But it will be a tricky balancing act.

Singapore sling

The stated goal is growth. If one was to turn to the toxic B-word, it’s a tentative step towards the Singapore-lite model of a ‘business first’ post-Brexit Britain.

Lower taxes, lighter regulation, and a smaller state (/safety net) traded off for higher growth.

Let’s leave aside whether this is anything like what most disgruntled working class Brexit supporters voted for. Once you add up any small pros and take away the huge cons, I don’t see any economic advantage for Brexit. But in purely economic terms, I’ve long said diverging from the European model towards a more cut-throat US-style capitalism is the closest we’ll get to neutering the economic downsides

Again, it’s not what I voted for. But there is an economic logic to it.

Still I remain skeptical about how far Britain can go in this direction.

We’re not Singapore – demographically, culturally, or geographically. We don’t live in small apartments in a single city with our elderly parents. UK politicians can enable sewage to be dumped in the sea, but the EU won’t allow shoddy goods to be dumped on the continent. We’ll have to meet the standards of our largest trading partner and it will naturally resist regulatory arbitrage on its borders.

As for state spending? We’re getting older and sicker. The National Health Service is the nearest thing the UK has to a religion. And I’d argue the population’s sense that government should solve its problems has only grown under the years of populist magical thinking.

It’s hard for me to see growth coming wide and fast enough to offset the pain from really taking an axe to state spending, if that’s the follow-up punch to come.

There’s an election coming in 2025. We’ll get a verdict then I suppose.

Interest rates could spoil the party

Making life even harder is the macro-economic backdrop that’s (mostly) neither of the government’s making nor under its control.

Inflation is rampant, and Truss has already (rightly) signed up to borrow billions to ease the energy crisis for individuals and businesses.

We are more or less at war with Russia – and if a few hundred billion is the ultimate price of victory (or even a negotiated stalemate) then it’ll be cheap compared to the priciest charges on the menu.

Yet while energy price caps should curb official inflation figures in 2023, still more borrowing piles greater pressure on the UK’s creaking balance sheet. That could be longer-term inflationary.

Already the Bank of England hiked interest rates this week by another 50 basis points, to 2.25%.

That’s the highest level since 2008. But scarier still is this chart (courtesy of Ed Conway from Sky News) showing how expectations for peak rates have soared in just a few months:

The expected peak is up by 2% to 4.75% in just a matter of weeks!

And while that might not sound especially high to old hands, Conway correctly highlights we’re far more indebted than when higher rates last prevailed.

Indeed he calculates that if rates were to hit 6% – outside expectations but again look at the rate of change above – then the mortgage burden would be similar to that which precipitated the property market crash of the early 1990s.

Debt markets are also a downer

We can then see the contours of the economic struggle taking shape.

The Truss government has decided to go for growth, as we used to put it. Today’s tax cuts take tens of billions a year out of the Government coffers and puts it back into our hands.

But the UK State is hugely indebted. And the cost of maintaining that debt is already soaring with rising interest rates.

Indeed the 10-year gilt yield jumped nearly 0.5% higher following Kwarteng’s mini-budget:

Source: MarketWatch

Lower taxes and austerity out the window means less fiscal tightening – perhaps even fiscal easing – exactly when we face huge inflationary pressure.

Which – given the Bank of England’s inflation target – in turn means higher interest rates. And that will strain household balance sheets and even risk a housing crash.

It sets up a push me pull you between the Chancellor and the Bank of England.

Politically this takes some pressure off Truss. Her government will be tax-cutters, leaving more money in people’s pockets. The Bank of England can be the bad guys, taking money back with higher rates.

The hope must be that faster growth will – among other things – reassure the capital markets and keep a lid on borrowing costs.

The risk is it doesn’t.

The pound has dropped nearly 2% this morning as gilt yields have risen.

I wouldn’t say that’s a huge vote of confidence, although to be fair it probably more reflects a ratcheting up of uncertainty.

Giving to Peter to pay Paul

How the push me pull me will resolve itself is anyone’s guess.

A similar-ish Thatcherite direction in the 1980s did deliver a growth spurt. I’d also argue it helped wrench Britain out of secular decline.

But inflation was a fading threat by the time the Thatcher boom really kicked in. We also had the windfall of North Sea oil revenues to paper over the cracks.

Perhaps a better way to conclude is to ask what this means for the typical Monevator reader who is saving hard and aiming for financial independence?

Well, firstly I don’t think it should change anyone’s long-term strategy.

Again, UK governments come along like buses these days. The 2025 General Election could easily shift things again.

But in broad strokes I’d say it’s tactically advantageous for us – but strategically less certain.

From a personal point of view, it’s hard to argue with lower taxes. More money in your pocket means more to save and invest.

I’d also imagine ISAs and SIPPs are safe under Truss and Kwarteng. Perhaps savings allowances – particularly the Lifetime Allowance for Pensions – could even start to rise again.

In the best-case scenario the UK escapes its low productivity trap, GDP grows, and we manage our expanding national debt thanks to higher cashflows from a larger base.

But there’s definitely a downside scenario to this steady accumulation of debt combined with more polarizing economic outcomes. (Plus I don’t see much here for infrastructure).

Careful what you wish for

The UK FIRE1 movement is also a kind of two-headed beast.

We benefit from laissez-faire policies in the accumulation phase – especially our favourable tax shelters like ISAs.

But we implicitly lean on state support as we keep taxes low in de-accumulation and – crucially – assume the NHS will be there to take care of our health needs.

Very different from US FIRE-seekers. They can earn and save more but face huge health insurance costs. This may keep them in jobs long after their British brethren would have called it a day.

There’s also the State pension to keep in mind. It’s a huge boon for the typical UK FIRE-ee.

Hence most of us wouldn’t benefit from too-much rolling back of the state and its services. Let alone grimmer potential scenarios that I won’t dwell on today.

Of course there’s not much we can do about it individually – aside from saving more, investing sensibly, paying attention, and hoping for the best.

But what do you guys think? Let us know – focusing on the economics rather than the politics, as much as you can – in the comments below.

  1. Financial Independence Retire Early. []
{ 184 comments }

Weekend reading: the upside of our high inflation

Weekend Reading logo

What caught my eye this week.

A few months ago I wrote about stress testing your mortgage ahead of higher interest rates. The threat has hardly abated, with the Financial Times noting that:

Borrowers now looking for another offer as their fixed period comes to an end will face much more expensive terms.

Average rates on a two-year fix have nearly doubled from 2.24 per cent a year ago to 4.24 per cent this week, according to finance website Moneyfacts.

The FT article (search result) adds that banks and building societies have pulled lots of mortgage products off the market, and they are being particularly quick to yank their most competitive mortgage deals.

The best table-topping rates might only be available for a few days before capacity is exhausted.

Hunting high and low

So far, so hairy.

Yet arguably we mortgage holders have never had it so good.

Because what would be spectacularly odd to any time traveler from the 1980s – who oddly chose to gawp at yield curves rather than, say, the iPhone – is the clear blue water between inflation and interest rates.

The UK CPI inflation figure favoured by the government and the ONS dipped unexpectedly this week. But it’s still at 9.9%.

The officially semi-defunct RPI figure that remains widely used in contracts is 12.3%.

Meanwhile the Bank of England’s Bank Rate is only 1.75%!

True, Bank Rate will surely be raised to 2.25% next week – it would already be there were it not for the period of national mourning – and given the state of core inflation I wouldn’t rule out a hike to 2.5%.

The pound falling adds even more pressure to raise rates. Sterling weakness makes imports (and commodities) even dearer – and we import a lot in Britain.

Yet even a 2.5% Bank Rate would be sat 8-10% below inflation, depending on how you measure the latter.

Whereas for most of my life – up until the financial crisis – interest rates ran well above inflation:

Source: Schroders

The Bank of England mandarins are of course familiar with this graph.

But from the start, this current inflationary episode has been seen as more a problem of supply than demand.

And despite a shocker in the US data this week, there are signs the inflationary impulses that set this ball rolling are, well, rolling over.

Inflation is still expected to fall back towards target by 2024. 

The sun always shines on TV

As for demand, does anyone have a sense the UK economy is roaring?

Not me.

Perhaps the housing market has been running a bit hot. But aside from that it would be a watered-down punchbowl that the Bank of England would be taking away were it to get rate-rise happy.

Even an expansionary fiscal plan from the new UK chancellor in his Budget next week would only be giddying-up what seems like a pretty stagnant economy.

It’d probably add a smidge to long-term inflation expectations, because just like last week’s energy relief plan it will likely add to long-term borrowing.

But I don’t see the Budget setting off one of those Tory booms that gets named after the chancellor later when the blame is doled out. (Barber, Lawson…)

An end to conflict in Ukraine would fire up the old animal spirits. But that might equally reduce some of the global price pressures and supply chain issues that were already easing before Putin sent in his tanks.

(Of course I’d take it regardless of its impact on the price of eggs or mortgages).

Take on me

Odd as it seems then, I’d bet five-year fixed rate mortgages will peak at around 4% – at least for this cycle.

Even with inflation running at high teen double-digits for a short while.

In other words, it probably won’t get much worse from here, from a borrower’s point of view.

Of course your guess is (almost…) as good as mine. Events can do a number on economic expectations, anytime, anywhere.

What’s more the Bank of England’s commendably honest and downbeat talk has not been matched by as aggressive a campaign of rate rises as we’ve seen from some of its peers. Maybe the rate-setters will lose their nerve?

Time will tell, but for now inflation is fast paying off your mortgage in real terms.

Enjoy it while it lasts!

[continue reading…]

{ 32 comments }

Weekend reading: how to get time on your side

Weekend reading: how to get time on your side post image

What caught my eye this week.

Time is something you can never have enough of when you’re compounding your way to financial freedom.

That’s because the big payoff from compound interest is back loaded.

In the early years, how much you can save from your income matters most.

But later on, your gains on money already socked away is usually what makes the biggest difference.

A return of say 10% on a near-retirement pot of £1,000,000 is an awful lot more than 10% on your first year’s savings of £5,000.

It’s £100,000 versus £500, to be precise about it.

Clearly the longer you can compound your money for, the better.

Unfortunately we can’t go back in time to begin earlier – the age-old lament of savers when compound interest first ‘clicks’ for them.

But in a novel post at On Dollars and Data, Nick Maggiulli suggests finding a few extra years further down the line as a way of boosting your returns:

How exactly?

According to the data, the answer is…exercise.

Exercising regularly to improve your strength and your cardiovascular health is the most effective way to increase how much time left you have on this Earth, all else equal.

I agree that personal fitness is an under-appreciated part of the game we’re all playing.

Few people would be happy to retire to fewer years than they might have enjoyed if they’d stayed in shape, or with not being able to do as much as they’d like due to physical limitations.

Not if they can help it, anyway. And Nick does his usual great job of marshaling the numbers to show that many of us can indeed help ourselves.

A solid exercise habit can be expected to add three to five years to your life, he finds.

Good, but even better getting fits means an additional six to eight years of your later years might be healthy – compared to if you’d done nothing.

Nick says:

You don’t need stress yourself out trying to save every penny. Instead, you exercise more, reduce your stress, and extend your life. This is a non-financial solution to a financial problem.

And while it might seem unorthodox, for those that are having trouble saving more, it might be the best option available.

Check out the full post, and then get moving!

Have a great weekend.

[continue reading…]

{ 25 comments }

Fixing your financial posture

Fixing your financial posture post image

Sooner than I’d like to think about, I’ll be 50-years-old.

Yikes. I was in my mid-30s when I wrote my first post on Monevator.

Unlike many people, I’ve always been very aware of the passing over time. This is not something that has snuck up on me.

I was barely 25 when the opening words of Kid Loco’s 1990s album A Grand Love Story smacked me between the ears:

“38 fucking years old…”

Only 13 years to go until I’d sound as broken as him!

Better get a move on.

Now here I am 25 years later and I’m not sure I really did.

But I can’t complain. Things have worked out okay.

Well, how did I get here?

Something that becomes apparent after you’ve lived for a few decades is that few of us methodically follow a plan to get where we want to go.

There’s no set directions. It’s not like a computer program. It’s barely like following the pictures in an IKEA leaflet.

Well, maybe some of the good bits are like the pictures. But not the rest.

This means that any life story – grand or otherwise – can only be told in retrospect.

Big picture, we never really know what’s going to happen.

The days go slow and the years go fast.

Still, we get on. We do things every day. And we don’t do other things that we said we were going to do.

It all accumulates. We shape our habits, consciously or otherwise, and afterwards they shape us.

These habits – reflexes, even – determine a lot of what we say, do, and achieve.

The work we put in. The breakfast we eat. How we sign off our emails. Whether we leave our friends happier than we found them.

The chances we turn down or back fearfully away from. Opportunities we seize too greedily. The ones we grasp just right.

Whether people think that we’re kind. Or greedy. Whether people forget us.

The stuff they talk about at funerals.

How do I work this?

Our lives are mostly our habits developed from birth and repeated for as long as we’re lucky to live for.

With interventions, of course. Whether from the outside world or – better – from within ourselves.

Your parents potty train you and stop you throwing your baby food on the floor.

You learn not to blurt out your feelings. If you’re lucky you develop a habit of reading books.

You take up weightlifting, or yoga. Try to make amends.

But there’s also a sort of entropy to habits. The ones we don’t care much about, or that we find too difficult – they fall into disrepair and disuse.

Your friendship circle shrinks because you didn’t pay attention. Your kids stop asking you questions after yet another brush off.

“Not now, I’m busy.”

If you wrote down the most important things in your life you’d say it was your family and friends.

But maybe your habits say otherwise.

Same as it ever was

Between the intentional habits we cultivate and the bad habits that find a home regardless, there’s always other habits coming into being.

Often they’re manifested by laziness – another birthright endowed to every one of us.

Nature is efficient, and seeks shortcuts. This shows up most obviously in your body.

If your arm is often reaching forward and your hand is usually sat upon a mouse, it’ll stop feeling awkward soon enough.

The weird posture will feel natural.

A child would fidget but an office worker might stay that way for hours.

Give it two decades and the cartilage in your arm adapts. Your shoulders are now permanently rolled forward. You’ve told your body to sit this way day after day, week after week. Your body listened.

Getting religion about stretching for a week every January won’t undo the damage.

One day you’re nearly 50 and people say you look good for your age but you know you’re an omni-shambles of impinged joints, slack abdominals, buggered knees, and eyestrain.

Some of this is inevitable. Ageing. But some of it you ordered up with your habitual choices, day after day.

You can try to undo it but it’s a slog. You’ll need to reprogram instructions hardwired by decades of repetition.

A lot of effort just to get back to the clean slate you began with.

Better to have had better habits. Better to have started fixing them years ago.

Otherwise better start now.

Am I right or am I wrong?

Money habits show up in our lives like the physical ones shape our bodies.

We start life without savings, debts, or much idea about what money is beyond the barter system.

Circumstances, upbringing, natural proclivities, and dumb luck begin to bring financial habits into our lives like freshly dug soil invites flowers and weeds.

Maybe as a kid you got a paper round. You were up every morning at 6am to earn a few quid each week. Perhaps the sheer heft of it made you value money. You saved most of what you earned. If you were really fortunate you saw it grow.

Your family was frugal and non-materialistic. They applauded your attitude.

40 years later and you’re writing a blog about investing. Financially free thanks to habits you barely knew you were cultivating.

Or maybe your family is very well-off. Your parents saw their parents strive and want to spare you the graft. You go to boarding school and are sent a generous allowance. It’s more than most of the other kids get – which makes you feel proud, so you show off – but it’s less than some – which makes you insecure.

40 years later you have a middle-sized house with a lot of front and a super-sized mortgage, three cars, and a spendthrift spouse. And no savings.

My god, what have I done?

Too convenient? Absolutely.

You grow up in a frugal, non-materialistic household. Get a paper round. Hoard your pennies. Truth be told you’re a bit of a tightwad. You equate work with money, and subconsciously think of net worth as self-worth. You save everything and scrounge pints off your friends. You have a boring job in a sector you don’t care much for because it pays well and there’s a solid pension plan.

40 years later you’re still renting because houses always look too expensive. You never married because you fear a costly divorce. You’re constantly frightened of losing your savings to a bear market and so you keep 80% of your money in cash.

Or… your family is rich. Your parents tell you there’s more to life than money. They saw their parents ground down by scrimping and saving. They send you a generous allowance while you’re away at school but they encourage you to invest half of it in the stock market. “Money is the key to making money” they tell you.

You watch them sell their small family business and re-invest the proceeds into property and shares. They’ve never been richer.

40 years later and you’re on your second start-up, having sold the first for a few million. It was touch-and-go, but your team never saw you wobble. Nor does your partner who loves your generosity of spirit as much as your financial firepower.

That said, your daughter reads a lot of FIRE1 blogs and tuts when you buy a holiday home in Ibiza…

Letting the days go by

There are a lot of ways to get from A to B in the game of life.

Quick. Roundabout. Some downright deadly.

We’re not all offered the same routes. But one thing we can all try to do is to cultivate the habits we want to take with us on the journey.

These habits will make us the people we want to be – or not. Regardless of whether we ever get to our destination.

  • If you want to be solvent, start saving any small amount of money. Develop the habit. Go from there.

  • Blowing the budget is your big bugbear? Start by thinking about the cost of every single little thing you buy.

  • You’re wary of risks and the stock market terrifies you. Don’t put 90% of your money into shares just because you read that’s appropriate for your age. Put in 10% and develop a feel for the market’s ups and downs. Find your sea legs. You can invest more when you forget why you were so frightened.

  • Worried you’re too stingy? Your shoulders are hunching and your arms are stuffed in your pockets. Your back is up, and turned away from your mates. Surprise everyone by paying for dinner. Tell them you got a bonus at work. Or your premium bonds came in. Who cares, brush it off. Or give £20 to the homeless guy outside M&S who – yes – looks like he could get a job. Or buy him lunch and give it to him on the way out.

Start somewhere. Change direction.

You won’t remember most of what you do out of habit. But they will be the ‘reps’ that build your financial posture, just as bicep curls give you guns.

It takes time.

Then one day someone will say you’re good with money. Ask your advice about investing. Buy you dinner as a thank you for something you didn’t even notice you did for them.

Because you did it out of habit.

Once in a lifetime

Sure you’ll remember the make-or-break moments when you look back on life.

That time you said yes to the weird person asking for your number. You married them! The job you agonized about leaving, only to land the opportunity of your dreams. Your first night in your first own home. Your baby smiling up at you. Antarctica. A lottery win.

But these are near-random escapades on a long road where mostly nothing much different happens.

Just maybe your good habits put you in the right place at the right time. But most of life is simply getting up every day and walking.

Why not stand tall, practically and metaphorically? Don’t shuffle and look at your feet and complain when you’re old that you can’t turn your neck.

Don’t do the wrong thing every day and wonder where your life took a wrong turn.

Try to do lots of little things right. Whatever right means for you.

Save a bit. Invest a bit. Give a bit.

It all adds up.

 

  1. Financial Independence Retire Early. []
{ 29 comments }