- Monevator - https://monevator.com -

Weekend reading: Is Kindle a tax on reading?

My weekly musing, followed by the regular link-fest of money and investing reads.

I have mixed feelings about Amazon’s Kindle book reader, which is about to come out in two cheaper and more powerful flavours.

At £149, the 3G Kindle [1] is keenly priced for a go-anywhere device. But it’s the less expensive Wi-Fi-only Kindle [2] that tempts me to forgo my bookshelves.

Books are one of my few spending weaknesses. I don’t buy many books that I don’t read, but it’s more than clothes I don’t wear or food I don’t eat. (I will get fat before I throw food out!)

Worse, these books accumulate despite my fairly cavalier habit of giving the ones I like to friends. My investing library alone is three shelves of double-stacked books deep, and I’ve got shelves and shelves of other books.

The book hoard is annoying on many levels:

I’ve recently got rid of over 300 magazines that I’d been carting around for a decade, and the temptation of now swapping my library for a Kindle [1] is high.

But do we really want to put every aspect of our art and culture onto a digital upgrade treadmill, as has already happened with movies and music?

True, Amazon keeps a record of what books you’ve bought. This means that when you upgrade your Kindle hardware, you don’t need to buy the books again.

But upgrading the Kindle every 2-3 years is still effectively a hefty tax on reading – perhaps £50 a year, amortized out, on top of the price of the books.

It’s certainly not the cheapest solution. Bookmooch [3] is just one of several book-swapping alternatives for frugalistas. The clever thing with this one is you don’t need to find an exact match with another member. Rather, you send books to whoever asks for them and accumulate points, which you can then ‘spend’ getting the books you want.

Perhaps authors should do more to promote digital readers like the Kindle [1]. They may lament the end of paper-based novels, but if the alternative is a swapping free-for-all, they’ve more to lose than the smell of a new paperback.

Pop over to Amazon [1] for the full specs of both Kindles; you may be surprised by how this technology has improved. I’ve used a friend’s previous generation Kindle at some length, and I thought it was great.

Money reads from the blogs

From the big sites

Subscribe [28] to get your weekend reading every Saturday!